We sandwiched her for a while without speaking, merely enjoying each other’s company, and being warm and naked. I closed my eyes, savoring the warmt... emanating from their bodies and the feel of skin-on-skin. I began stroking Amanda’s inner thigh gently, and as I opened my eyes, I noticed Dimitri was touching her, too. I looked at him across Amanda’s body, and smiled. Then we both leaned forward and kissed each other in front of my wife. She ran her fingers through our hair and kept our faces. "Craigslist?" I asked. We had read all the ads and considered replying so many times, but always chickened out. Yet, something in her eyes and tone told me this time was different."Set it up for after the weddings," she suggested. "I get my period in a couple of days."I laughed, "Yeah, we should probably wait until that is over."The next few days flew by and other than a quick blow job before she headed to the airport, we hadn't had sex since that crazy night.After she was gone, I started going. Taking them out I started playing with her butt hole. I played around the rim a bit, then I put each finger into the first knuckle. I kept playing and she kept getting more responsive. Soon I was up to three fingers plunging away at her ass. "Moment of truth baby" I said as I lined my dick up with her hole. I got it nice and lubed with some Astroglide and started to push my dick into her.She gasped and bit her lip, but she didn't pull away and sat tight waiting for me. I took my time because I. " You're full of shit. I don't know what kind of game you're playing, Melanie, but you're playing one." The only game I'm playing, Mitchell Zarelli, is sex. I like sex. I found out the other day that you're good at it." Well, you're going to have to find someone else that's good at it. Look, me sleeping with you hurt Callie badly." That's her problem, Mitch! How many fucking opportunities has she had with you? You're turning down sex because of misguided loyalty to a girl who is not only out of.