It didn’t last long though because they didn’t want to sweat off their make-up. We guys then continued playing two on two. Shirts vs. Skins. ‘H...y Zac, you can double with me. Now we can play good-looking guys onto the dopey-looking ones,’ Billy joked. He sure had a lot of confidence. ‘Fine with us, but if you two are so good-looking you can go skins and we’ll ask what the girls think.’ Billy shrugged and pulled of his shirt and flexed his muscles for the chicks. They cheered, building his. As my cock slowly stretched her pussy I put my finger on mouth and softly said shhh. From then she was lost in ecstasy. She got carried away every time I slid up and rubbed the base of the shaft of my cock against her clit while my cock is in her pussy. It was less than 5 minutes, I guess, before she climaxed the first time. She opened her legs and far as she could, lifted her legs as high as she could and pulled my cock all the way into her – literally all the way to the balls. In fact my. I would be the first guy in her ass and she would be the first girl I ever fucked in the ass. My cock became rock hard at the thought of my shaft disappearing into her tight hole. Sarah was about to let go of my cock when all of a sudden a couple thick drops of cum landed right on Sarah’s arm, and I felt all the excitement from moments ago flood out. Sarah didn’t say anything, but the half-cocked eyebrow and frown blatantly displayed her frustration. I profusely apologized but Sarah cut me off. I didn't want to hear reason right now! I'd been taken nearly completely by surprise by a semi-retired master thief who 'didn't use guns'. Any Watters two-bit gunsel behind that door could have done the exact same thing and with much more lethal results! Right now only my pride was hurt ... but it was stung pretty darned badly!"Fine, you had the jump on me, knowing that I was there. But why couldn't you have just announced yourself first?" The door was bit too thick for you to have been certain.