I looked around before going in to make sure nobody noticed us, but sure enough the church ladies had the driver busy and were headed for the cafeteri... to get some tea. As the bathroom door shut behind me, Earl locked the door and quickly dropped his pants to the floor. He pulled me to him and planted a hungry wet kiss on my lips which I happily returned. I fumbled with my belt and oped up my jeans to allow his bare hands into my boxers. Earl softly gripped my cock and began to slowing wank me.. Bases loaded, one out, top of the ninth. Tailor made double play ball to Ed. Right through his legs. On purpose. Runs score, Lily loses, Ed laughs." You'd never. You like winning too much," Lily told him."I think you just lost me," I admitted."Baseball. Lily's our star pitcher." Really?" I said, surprised. A girl was the star pitcher?"Yup," Mike put in."I love baseball," Lily told me. "And, yeah, I'm good. Mike's on the team too, he's our catcher. Frankie's one of our other pitchers and center. He got his whole body into it, and I took hold of his firm ass, feeling it flex and harden as he worked his dick in and out of my tight butt. Our chests brushed together, our bodies working as one. I looked up at him."Oh man, your ass is getting me off so bad," he said."I can't believe we're doing this," I said."I'm gonna fuck you ever Sunday from now on," he said. "Every Sunday and every chance I get, I want to fuck you." Same here, man, same here." One breathless instant later I was kissing. He then pulled it out of my butt and told me to stay on the sofa and he would be right back. He left the room and came back a couple minutes later with this red thing that looked like a bulb or something. He told me that it was called a butt plug and that as part of my punishment. I had to wear it! I was puzzled at first but then dad shoved it in my ass and it hurt it was so big! He finally got it in me and told me to keep it in my asshole until he told me I could take it out. Honestly, after.